Sunday, July 1, 2012

Top Ten Paleo-Myths of Edumucated Folks: Paleo-Myth # 9 - The Mesozoic Was Hot While the Cenozoic Was Cold

By the time kids figure out the age of mammals was distinct and separate from the age of reptiles they have also had impressed upon them that the two ages were very distinct climatically as well. The time of the dinosaur is portrayed as a time of perpetual "hothouse" conditions- with greenhouse tropical climes extending pole to pole. And after the dinosaurs the earth plunged into ice age conditions where emblematic shaggy fossil mammals such as the woolly mammoth tromped across glacier landscapes.

But the reality of the situation is far more complex.

Mesozoic Cool Down?

A growing body of evidence is mounting that suggests that the climate throughout the Mesozoic was not always as hot as was once assumed. The famous "Jehol biota" of Liaoning, northeastern China is now thought to be representative of an early Cretaceous global cooldown. Famous for its diverse assemblage of fuzzy small theropods/early birds- the site made headlines earlier this year with the discovery of the first truly large feathered theropod, the tyrannosaur Yutyrannus huali.

If you would like to read further on temperate Liaoning here is an excellent summary on this fascinating ecosystem of fuzzy dinos, dino eating  mammals, and inland seas.

Cenozoic Hothouse: Palm Trees in Alaska

The idea of the age mammals being a cold one is so enmeshed in most people's minds that the average person would be hard pressed to name a prehistoric mammal that is not an ice age mammal.

The brontothere Brontops which lived in the Eocene
But the climate situation in the Cenozoic is actually very bipolar. Let's consider the Eocene period. From your god Wikipedia:

The Eocene Epoch contained a wide variety of different climate conditions that includes the warmest climate in the Cenozoic Era and ends in an icehouse climate. The evolution of the Eocene climate began with warming after the end of the Palaeocene-Eocene Thermal Maximum (PETM) at 56 million years ago to a maximum during the Eocene Optimum at around 49 million years ago. During this period of time, little to no ice was present on Earth with a smaller difference in temperature from the equator to the poles. Following the maximum, was a descent into an icehouse climate from the Eocene Optimum to the Eocene-Oligocene transition at 34 million years ago. During this decrease ice began to reappear at the poles, and the Eocene-Oligocene transition is the period of time where the Antarctic ice sheet began to rapidly expand.

And some of the best evidence for the balmy period of the Eocene is fossil plants. From Wikipedia:

Polar forests were quite extensive. Fossils and even preserved remains of trees such as swamp cypress and dawn redwood from the Eocene have been found on Ellesmere Island in the Arctic. The preserved remains are not fossils, but actual pieces preserved in oxygen-poor water in the forests of the time and then buried before they had the chance to decompose. Even at that time, Ellesmere Island was only a few degrees in latitude further south than it is today. Fossils of subtropical and even tropical trees and plants from the Eocene have also been found in Greenland and Alaska. Tropical rainforests grew as far north as northern North America and Europe. 
Palm trees were growing as far north as Alaska and northern Europe during the early Eocene, although they became less abundant as the climate cooled. Dawn redwoods were far more extensive as well.

The Eocene lasted about 20 million years. In contrast the Quaternary,  the period of glaciation known as the ice ages, has only been going for about 2.6 million years. One can make a case that not only is the Cenozoic not characterized by glaciations- but that these conditions are in fact the exception not the rule.

Eocene North America

Support me on Patreon.
Like antediluvian salad on facebook.
Watch me on Deviantart @NashD1.Subscribe to my youtube channel Duane Nash.

No comments:

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...